Adam Shields

Takeaway: Erickson focuses on how to disagree well and evaluate different Christian positions. 

As I have been reading about the trinity over the past two years I have realized that it is actually fairly small questions that are at the root of the big debates.

This makes sense because Christians agree about the vast majority of Christian theology. There is very little debate about the fact that the Trinity has three members.  That all three members of the trinity are God. Or that the Trinity is made up of the Father, Son and the Holy Spirit.

But a relatively small debate has gained importance over the last 30-50 years because of another debate within the church, the role of women.

Read more

This book is free today on Kindle, so I am reposting this review from 2010.

Takeaway: Short, very informative book about the state of beer in the world from a professor of beer.  Not really about the soul or really any other religious thoughts on beer.

I have a somewhat mixed relationship with beer.  On the one hand, I like beer and I drink it fairly often, although in quite moderate amounts.  On the other hand I come from a family that is historically against drinking and from a church background that still has a hard time dealing with alcohol.

My grandmother was raised by an alcoholic father and she dropped out of high school to support her family because he was so often out of work because of his alcoholism.  She later went back to high school, graduated from college, became a teacher and raised 8 children.  She passed on her strong views of alcohol to most of her children and that passed on to many of the grandchildren.

For church background, I do not remember any strong messages on alcohol other than it was not talked about and not drank publicly.  I went to college where we signed a pledge not to drink alcohol as long as we were enrolled.  So I did not really start drinking until my mid-20s.  (I went to seminary at University of Chicago Divinity School where much of the proceeds of the student coffee shop went to parties with lots of alcohol served.  I did not really participate much.)  It was really after seminary that I started hanging with a different church crowd that had a more tolerant view of the proper use of alcohol.

Read more

Summary: An Archdeacon, with a fondness for drink, seeks after his debutante.

The Church of England Series continues to enthrall me.  As I write this I am almost finished with the fourth book of the series I have read in less than a month.

I am normally not a fan of Christian fiction.  But this is not normal Christian fiction.  First, it is oriented around the Church of England in the early and mid-20th Century.  Second, it is primarily about clergy that are in need of spiritual counsel and redemption.

Third it is not Christian Fiction that has a salvation story and then all is right with the world.  Instead, as with the first two books of the series, the redemption story happens fairly early in Ultimate Prizes and then the rest of the book is about how the main character deals with the fact that he got what he wanted.

Read more

Summary: Smiley catches Karla’s trail again.

This is the sixth George Smiley I have read since August.  It is also the third of the sub-trilogy that started with Tinker, Tailor, Solider, Spy.

Overall this is one of the best of the series.  If you are not a stickler for reading series in order, then the three best of the series are Tinker, Tailor, The Spy Who Came in from the Cold and Smiley’s People.

In Smiley’s People, George Smiley has again retired.  At the conclusion of the Honorable Schoolboy, Smiley had lost his shine.  He and his people had found Karla’s plot, but the British Intelligence system was in disgrace, they did not capture Karla, Smiley’s agent was killed and the USA had swooped in and claimed the little credit that was left to claim.

Read more