Guest Post on Reading

My friend Vikki asked me to write a guest post about six months ago.  I kept forgetting to write it and so she re-asked again yesterday.  I kept with my original idea about why I think we need to intentionally re-read books.  It is up now.

The Next Story by Tim Challies (Authority and Truth)

The Next Story: Life and Faith after the Digital ExplosionTakeaway: Conceptions of Authority and Truth are changing, the question is are they changing because of culture or technology. And if they are changing, is it a bad thing?

My general review of The Next Story: Life and Faith After The Digital Explosion is basically very positive.  I do not want to distract from the fact that in general I think this was a very helpful book and one that many people would benefit from reading.  But the parts that I most disagreed with revolved around Challies understanding of truth and authority.

Initially, Challies has a discussion of Russell Ackoff‘s DIKW model.  Ackoff suggests that we move from Data (simple description) to Information (answers basic questions like who, what, where, when) to Knowledge (information that has been owned and processed so a person can interact with other types of information) and finally to Wisdom (the application of knowledge, life experience to make good decisions).  Data and information about about the accumulation.  Knowledge is about the comparisons.  And wisdom is about the application.

Challies makes the very useful progression a focus of how our use of education has changed.  Rote memory is much less important because the basic facts are always available. The problems according to Challies, Nicholas Carr and others is that we are in a race to accumulate data and information and do not seem to spend much time with knowledge and wisdom.  Part of this is availability of information.  If a person only has access to dozens of books you will think much more about the individual books and ideas within the books.  If you have access to virtually unlimited data then the inclination is to spend less time on any particular idea.  In many ways, I think this is true partially.  Many people know lots about a little.  But increased specialization also means that people have more time, and are rewarded because they know a lot about a few things.  So while I think that for the average person, there might be a temptation toward data/information and not knowledge/wisdom, I do not think this true of society as a whole.

Read more

No Argument for God: Going Beyond Reason in Conversations About Faith by John Wilkinson

No Argument for God: Going Beyond Reason in Conversations About FaithTakeaway: A faith that can be fully understood by science or logic is no longer faith.  As Christians we need to embrace that Christianity is above human logic.

I am not a fan of apologetics.  In general I do not read it and I think primarily the purpose it serves is to help Christians feel comfortable in their faith.  I know that over simplifies things, but if even I, who am a long term Christian with a very good theology background see all kinds of logical holes in most apologetics books I do not think it is really going to move a large segment of people to faith.  My pastor has said several times, that people rarely have theological issues with God, they have emotional issues with God that they may hide behind theological issues.  But when you push, usually the theological questions fall away and the emotional issues come back.  So I have been hoping someone would write No Argument for God.

Wilkinson starts by asserting that Christianity is nonsense.  By that he means that is really is beyond our ability to understand completely through our senses and therefore literally “nonsense” (above the senses).  Much of the first half of the book is biographical to help the reader understand the limitations of reason and different ways to talk about Christianity.  My favorite part of this section is a discussion about what science and logic can determine.  Wilkinson says science and logic are good at understanding the “What” questions.  If we ask “Why” questions, “Why is that flower there?”, science is limited in its ability to respond.  Science can talk about how it evolved to have those colors or how it fits into the biosphere around it but science and logic cannot really give an answer to Why that does not become circular.

Read more

Ideas for the next book discussion

I would love to get some ideas for another book discussion. These are three books that I thought might discuss well but I am wide open to other books. 1) No Argument for God: Going Beyond Reason in Conversations About Faith by John Wilkinson (amazon link) update: my review   I just received a review copy of … Read more

Naked Economics: Undressing the Dismal Science by Charles Wheelan

Rating: 4 Stars Purchase Links: Hardcover, Paperback, Kindle Edition, Audible.com Audiobook Economics has always been fascinating to me. I regret never taking an economics class in college. This book broke down a lot of economics principles into an accessible format that left me wanting to learn more. I wouldn’t call it Economics for Dummies. It’s … Read more

Many Ways to Say I Love You: Wisdom for Parents and Children from Mr Rogers

Many Ways to Say I Love You: WISDOM FOR PARENTS AND CHILDREN FROM MISTER ROGERSTakeaway: Mr Rogers really was wise.

Purchase Links: Hardcover, Kindle Edition, Audible.com Audiobook

Over the weekend there were a bunch of sales on kindle books.  I picked this up for $0.44.  And at that price is was a steal.  The kindle price is now up to almost $10 so much less attractive.

This is a very short books, in paper it looks like a gift book size.  In audio it is only 75 minutes.

It was edited by Fred Roger’s wife from various speeches and articles that he wrote.  Each page has a few lines, just one thought. There are a couple roughly themed chapters, but really this is intended to be browsed through looking for the nugget that will speak to you where you are right now.

I do not have kids of my own, but nanny my two nieces (2 and 3).  I think I highlighted about a third of the book.  What Mr Rogers seems to be good at is encouraging parents to be good parents.  This seems to be the theme of the book:

Looking back over the years of parenting that my wife and I have done with our two boys, I feel good about who we are and what we’ve done. I don’t mean we were perfect parents. Not at all. Our years with our children were marked by plenty of inappropriate responses. Both Joanne and I can recall many times when we wish now we’d said or done something different. But we didn’t, and we’ve learned not to feel too guilty about that. What gives me my good feelings is that we always cared and always tried to do our best. Our two sons are very different one from the other; yet, at the core of each of them there seems to be a basic kindness, a caring, and a willingness to try. I’ve heard young parents complain about the way they were treated by their own parents, and they say, “œI’ll never make that mistake with my kids!” And probably the most honest response to that is, “œPerhaps you won’t make that mistake, but you’ll surely make your own different ones.” Well, we certainly made our share of mistakes.

Read more

Isaac Newton by James Gleick

Isaac NewtonTakeaway: Sometimes it is ok to give up.

Purchase Links: Hardback, Paperback, Kindle Edition Audible.com Audiobook

I am intrigued by science.  But I really do not know much about science.  My science education was either quite poor, or I am just a poor science student (or both.)  My high school biology class was taught by a teacher that had two sections, one was for people that had already failed biology once and the second was taught with the same outline.  I never received less than a 90 on any test or quiz, but I am not sure I learned anything either.  My chemistry class I remember distinctly people cheating off of me, but I have no memory of the class other than the oddity that was my teacher.  I took AP physics but remember it even less than the other two.  In college I had one science class which I hated.  It was filled almost entirely by music majors because of off scheduling and a professor that did not like students.

Read more

How to Pray by R. A. Torrey

Takeaway: There is something unique about the authors on Prayer in the late 19th and early 20th century. Purchase Links: Google Books (free ebook), christianaudio.com Audiobook, Kindle Edition, Paperback I found this as a free audiobook somewhere (I think it was christianaudio.com but I cannot find a free copy right now.)  So when I was looking … Read more

Sacred Unions, Sacred Passions: Chap 7

When Harry Met Sally...
Image via Wikipedia

It’s been said that females and males can’t be friends because of the big S word involved…..that friendship without sex equals questionable intentions (blame When Harry met Sally!). I’ve always found that to be a very simplistic and stereotypical view of men and women relationships. I personally, have been able to have two very close platonic male friends (they were “bridesmen” in my wedding). As a woman in the book quotes, we have never nor will we ever engage in any sexual intimacy. Instead, we laugh, we talk, and we share stories. I often find myself getting offended that people, especially church people (not all but some!) have relayed to me that having male friends somehow conflicts with God’s view of marriage and intimacy. Luckily, in this book, it seems Mr. Dan Brennan is on my side!

This author presents a different perspective from existing church culture. “Christ came not to just reduce the old disorder of lust, violence, and possession between men and women ,but to usher us into a new world of embodied communication with each other.” He submits that it is possible to live together in Christ without lust or sexual innuendos interfering with the friendship. In focusing on the fact that we are brothers and sisters in Christ, our focus shifts onto our common bond of Christianity rather than our own temptations and desires.

Read more